Southam Poll Questions Questionable
Special Editorial Section
by Barrie Zwicker
MONTREAL — At $200,000, it was expensive. It was carefully
planned by intelligent people. The results were widely published in
early October as "The Searching Nation" series.
But this poll, conducted for Southam Press Ltd.,
has come under such fire that there is now a general reassessment of
polls in editorial offices across the country.
The majority of questioners from the working media
at the national seminar on the press and the confederation debate were
searching for answers to questions such as:
- Why did the poll refer to "Prime Minister"
Trudeau but "Mr." Levesque?
- Why did a question refer to the media's
"promoting" national unity rather than, for instance, "informing the
public about" national unity issues?
- Why did the poll dwell on questions about
possible civil war and the form such a war might take? "I hated the
insistence (on the possibility of civil war) ... will we fight with a
knife, a fork ..." teased Solange Chaput-Rolland at a seminar workshop.
Mme. Chaput-Rolland is a 25-year veteran journalist, author
and broadcaster and a member of the Task Force on National Unity.
Communications professor Gerald Alperstein of the
University of Evansville, Evansville, Ind., whose expertise includes
polling, said a Southam question on the media "was probably one of the
worst questions that has ever been written." The question required a
single answer but related, Alperstein noted, to 12 answer areas.
Sitting on an evening panel focussed on the
survey, four of its creators refused to back down. "Premier Levesque
could have written many passages himself," said Paddy Sherman,
publisher of the Vancouver Province.
(Levesque at noon the same day had quoted a La Presse editorial
characterizing the survey as "ill-conceived, ill-structured,
badly-written and badly-interpreted.")
The consensus seemed to be that the poll was
generally interesting and useful as an indicator of attitudes among
Canadians outside Quebec at one point in time, but that the Quebec
results were questionable.
The nature of a number of the questions and the
rendering of the results (especially some headlines, including the one
saying a million people might leave Quebec) were most criticized and
least ably defended.
Published in Content's SOURCES December 1977
Sources, 489 College Street,
Suite 305, Toronto, ON M6G 1A5.
Phone: (416) 964-7799 FAX: (416) 964-8763
Directory Include yourself
Mailing Lists and
Names & Numbers Sources Calendar
Names & Numbers