MRG Calls OMA Ad Campaign Misleading
The Medical Reform Group of Ontario today asked the Ontario Medical
Association to cease their misleading advertising to their members
and the public. Dr. Philip Berger, a Toronto family doctor and spokesman
for the group called upon the leadership of the OMA to provide accurate
information and to accept the proposed ban on extra billing. Berger
said that properly conducted studies have shown that extra billing
does deter some patients from seeking medical care and is not a
"smokescreen" for other issues as the OMA has claimed.
The OMA has asserted that the "real" problems are underfunding
and lack of chronic care beds and high technology equipment.
Berger charged that the OMA has buried a Canadian Medical Association
report on the funding of the health care system because its conclusions
contradict their own. Joan Watson, a former host of CBC's Marketplace,
chaired the task force which reported in 1984. Two of the five commissionaires
were doctors while the others were Roy Romanow, former Attorney-General
of Saskatchewan and the Hon. Pauline McGibbon, former Lieutenant-Governor
of Ontario. The task force concluded that, given the health system's
existing inefficiencies there was no evidence for the CMA's and
OMA's claim that there was "dangerous underfunding". The
task force did find evidence of maldistribution of resources and
personnel within the present system.
The commission found that Canada's rate of institutionalization
of its elderly was 80% higher than the United States and 90% higher
than Great Britain. It recommended that Canada develop alternatives
to what it referred to as "the callous practice of warehousing
the elderly." CMA Task Force (p.37). Finally, the task
force found much of our highly-touted, high technology is insufficiently
evaluated and inappropriately used.
The CMA report cost over $500,000 but the OMA has refused to spend
the estimated $50,000 to distribute copies to its membership. Dr.
Berger said that a member of the MRG who is also a member of the
OMA had sent $100 to the OMA asking them to distribute the CMA task
force report but his cheque was returned. Berger said further,
"Medicine, and the science upon which medicine is founded are
premised on the pursuit of knowledge. This fundamental tenet of
medicine applies to basic scientific research, accurate diagnoses
of patient problems, and epidemiological analyses of health care
systems. Whatever the area of medicine physicians must consider
all available evidence and then present their impressions honestly
and clearly to their patients or the public. The OMA leadership
has strayed off the course of scientific inquiry and search for
knowledge. Its current advertising campaign reflects badly on the
ethics and the practice of medicine."
Berger called upon the OMA to withdraw its advertising campaign
and correct its misinformation.
The MRG also reaffirms its opposition to the OMA's call for physicians
to discuss the proposed ban on extra billing with their patients.
The group feels it is unethical for doctors to initiate political
discussions with their patients.
For further information:
Dr. Philip Berger
Dr. Michael Rachlis
Subject Headings: Abortion
Health Centres Drug
Care Budgets Health
Care Cost Containment Health
Care Costs Health
Care Delivery Health
Care Finance & Fund-Raising Health
Care in Canada Health
Care in Ontario Health
Care in the U.K. Health
Care in the U.S. Health
Care Myths Health
Care Reform Health
Care Resources Health
Care Services Health
Care Workers Health
Service Organizations Health/Social
Justice Issues Health
Human Resources Medical
Research Funding Medicare
Health & Safety Patients'
Human Resources Pro-Choice
Toronto, Ontario, , Canada Tel: 416–964–5735
Copyright © Sources, All rights reserved.